fbpx

Why should you buy a house in Montauk?

If you are planning to live in the Hamptons region of New York, you probably need to anticipate your budget to find a home and make it your own. It is not uncommon for people to spend millions upon millions of dollars when they are looking for luxury homes or mansions. 

The area of Montauk is an upscale area, but it’s actually usually more affordable than other parts of the Hamptons. And it features a ton of locations and events that you can’t find anywhere else, including in other parts of the Hamptons.  

For those reasons, and many others, many people are flocking to Montauk and hoping to call it home in the years ahead. The popularity of this location has skyrocketed over the last decade, and it’s been harder and harder to buy a house in Montauk. This is especially true for anyone trying to find luxury houses, luxury villas, and luxury mansions in Montauk. 

The truth is that if you are hoping to buy a house in Montauk, there is a lot you need to know. You need to be familiar with the area, the businesses, and events, and all the things to be aware of when shopping for a home and exploring the area. Luckily, our guide can give you access to everything you need to know about Montauk and the particular real estate market there.  

How much does it cost to live in Montauk? 

Although Montauk might be considered a more affordable area to live in in the Hamptons, you still need to take your budget into consideration. As of Q2 2024, the median home price in Montauk was about $1,800,000 according to the Samuel Miller market report. This includes locations in the most popular neighborhoods, such as East Great Plains, South New London, Taftville, and others.  

The homes in the Hamptons aren’t on the market long. They are typically sold about 130 days after they are listed, which shows the interest in this region. And there aren’t too many homes for sale either, with around 73 listings on the market as of Q2 2024. 

Living in Montauk isn’t inexpensive, but it’s a far more affordable part of the Hamptons than others such as South Hamptons, East Hamptons, and more. This is one of the most attractive features for many when it comes to Montauk. 

Why buy a house in Montauk? 

You will always have something fun, unique, and special to do when you’re living in Montauk. Even people who don’t live in the area sometimes travel great distances so that they can enjoy the businesses and events that are only found in Montauk.

If this part of the country is going to be your new home, you need to be aware of the things that you will get to experience. There is a lot that will keep your days – and nights – busy and exciting.

From local bars to coffee shops, beachfront parties, and parks, Montauk truly does have something for everyone if you know what to look for and where to find it.  

Food 

You have never had pizza like the type you will find at Robert’s Montauk, which is known for its wood-fired pizza and delicious drinks and large bar. This has long been one of the most popular eateries in the area – and with good reason too.  

If you’re looking for delicious cuisine straight from Uruguay, Marram will be right for you and will offer you a slew of delicious daily-rotating dishes with the most delectable delicious meats and roasted veggies.  

Few eateries will leave a memory as lasting as one made at Montauket, which offer American dishes and live music with a gorgeous view right on the water. Take in the sunset, enjoy some local beers, and look out at the bay. When you’re eating your meal at Montauket, you’ll realize that life doesn’t get much better than this.  

Outdoors 

If you’re looking for something to do outdoors in Montauk, then you are in luck. There is not just one or two things to do in this area, there is in fact so much to do that it will feel like you never have enough time to do it all.  

Of course, you could spend days upon days lounging on the beaches of Montauk, but there is even more to do than just that. For example, you can take a unique Montauk lighthouse tour via bike, or you can explore the history of the area and walk through classic buildings that are more than 100 years old.  

Do you want to get up and close and personal with the seals that live in the area? What about taking a cruise on the water as the sun goes down? Maybe enjoy an outdoor concert with a yummy glass of wine along with friends and family? All of these things are possible in Montauk. There are many year-round and annual activities that people enjoy when moving to the area.

Summary

Montauk is known for its beach-front beauty that is unparalleled, even in other areas of the Hamptons. It truly is a beautiful, picturesque region that is well worth the experience. But if you are hoping to find a luxury house or mansion that can be yours in Montauk, you need to make sure you only turn to the experts. At BARNES New York, you will find a team that knows the market well, what to look for, what to avoid, and what to keep in mind with the luxury real estate market. Contact us today to discuss your future and any possible move to Montauk and beyond.  

Contact Us

What is the real estate market like in the Hamptons?

Like most residential areas outside of big cities, the Hamptons have seen a tremendous influx of home buyers and residences since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. People want to live outside the city more than ever while still remaining somewhat close, and the housing market reflects that.

Like most of the world, the Hamptons has a competitive housing market where buyers enter bidding wars against other buyers to land the house. Because of that, areas of the Hamptons that have been harder to sell in have suddenly become a buyer’s destination. And with some revitalizations of shopping districts and nearby downtowns, those areas have become even more desirable.

About How Many Residences Are on the Market Today?

At the time of writing, over a thousand homes were for sale or rent in the Hamptons, with listing prices ranging from approximately $400,000 on the more inland properties up to $78,000,000 for the oceanfront properties. When considered over the entire year, rental prices start at around $14,000 annually and go up from there.

The listings, as described above, are located throughout the Hamptons, from the westernmost stretch (Westhampton, Westhampton Beach, and Eastport) to the eastern tip (East Hampton, Amagansett, and Montauk).

Where is the best place to live in the Hamptons?

Of course, this leans a little on personal preference: do you like oceanfront properties more than wooded inland ones? Or do you prefer properties closer to restaurants, shops, and museums? But, with that being said, and with so many real estate options in the Hamptons, there is something that will fit within your ideals.

What is the upside to Westhampton?

Of the Hamptons, Westhampton is the closest neighborhood to New York City. By car, it is just under 1 hour and 30 minutes to Midtown Manhattan, making it the ideal location for those who would like to commute to the city frequently. Because of this, Westhampton has seen some upswing in the amount of purchases lately.

Couple that with a revitalized downtown, its proximity to the water, and it’s clear that Westhampton will continue its upward trajectory.

What is the upside to East Hampton?

Montauk

Farther away from New York City is East Hampton, a quieter area in the Hamptons. For reference, by car, it is just under a 2-hour drive from Manhattan (near Central Park). It has a thriving downtown with plenty of charm and accommodations and is perfect for those wanting to experience New York without all of the crowds and business of the big city. It also has incredible views, plenty of parks with hiking trails, and long, scenic beaches.

Of course, with such features and accommodations, East Hampton real estate has seen an uptick in buyers lately and can be competitive.

How competitive is real estate in the Hamptons?

According to the Hamptons Real Estate Report by Hedges, the Hamptons real estate market has declined in terms of the number of sold listings. However, the amount of each sale had increased over the previous year, meaning that even though fewer properties were sold, the amount they sold for was higher.

The reason for the increase in sale prices can be pinpointed to two reasons. The first reason being that it costs construction companies more money to build properties due to the uptick in labor and material costs throughout the world.

The other reason also relates to construction. Again, because of the cost to build (and the material shortage), companies just can’t build new properties as frequently as they had before. And for that reason, there are fewer properties for potential buyers. That means for those that are on the market, the lack of properties make it ultra-competitive, and potential buyers often have to enter bidding wars against other buyers.

Any recommendations for property buying in the Hamptons?

Beautiful brown mansion with a driveway and a fountain.

There are many property and real estate opportunities in the Hamptons despite the decline in the number of sold listings—almost every village, town, and hamlet within the Hamptons has property for sale. It then becomes a matter of where you want to live; or where you can afford to live. For those looking to spend upwards of 10 million dollars, the oceanside properties of East Hampton, Amagansett, or Montauk would be of interest.

Those hoping to spend less than 10 million dollars but still desire an oceanside property should look to Westhampton, Westhampton Beach, Eastport, or the areas around those villages. And for those not wanting to spend a million dollars, looking at the villages and hamlets more inland would lead to desirable options.

What does the future of real estate in the Hamptons look like?

Because of the pandemic, the Hamptons has seen an influx of buyers gobbling up their real estate supply at record rates. Rates which, largely due to material shortages, construction companies and contractors haven’t been able to keep up with. As a result, not only had the Hamptons seen a decrease in the number of sales, but it had also experienced a decrease in supply.

However, with many companies leaning more on remote workers than ever before, several agencies and real estate heads are predicting a more stable and ‘normal’ market for the Hamptons in the future. To check out all the finest luxury listings available, alongside expert advice and guidance, be sure to contact BARNES New York.

WhatsApp
en_USEnglish